Dark Souls · 2011
Dark Souls: the interlocking masterpiece that taught a generation to persevere
Dark Souls review: FromSoftware's 2011 action RPG built a genre from punishing combat and a brilliantly interconnected world, despite a weaker second half.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Dark Souls is one of the most influential games of its century. The term Soulslike exists because of it, and a vast range of action games, from blockbuster adventures to independent platformers, have borrowed its ideas about checkpoints, difficulty and environmental storytelling. More than that, it remains a superb game in its own right.
- 9.4
- Editorial score
- #9
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2011
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Gameplay
What makes it special is less its difficulty, which is often overstated, than its trust. It trusts players to explore without a map, to learn from failure and to piece together a story from fragments.
Returning to the central shrine from an unexpected direction is one of the defining sensations in the medium.
How it plays
Combat is slow, heavy and deliberate. Every swing commits the character to an animation, stamina governs attacks, blocks and rolls, and reckless button-pressing is punished. Enemies are learned through repetition, and the sense of mastery when a once-terrifying knight becomes routine is enormously satisfying.
Death costs souls, the currency used for levelling and purchases, which can be recovered only by reaching the spot where the player fell. Bonfires restore healing flasks but respawn enemies, creating a constant tension between pressing on and turning back.
Build variety is broad, with sorcery, miracles, pyromancy and a wide range of weapons and armour. Some approaches are notably more forgiving than others, which gives players a way to tailor the challenge.

World and story
Lordran is the game's greatest achievement. The first half in particular is a marvel of interconnection, with areas that loop back on themselves, lifts and doors that reveal shortcuts, and distant landmarks that later become reachable. Returning to the central shrine from an unexpected direction is one of the defining sensations in the medium.
Anor Londo, a sunlit city of gods, is a high point of both design and atmosphere. Unfortunately, later areas are less polished. Fast travel arrives and weakens the sense of place, and a few zones feel noticeably unfinished, with repetitive enemies and awkward bosses.
The story is minimal on the surface: a prophecy, a bell to ring, a flame fading. Beneath that lies an intricate mythology conveyed through item descriptions, cryptic characters and architecture. Players can finish the game with little idea of what happened, or spend years unpicking it.
Presentation
Art direction outweighs technical fidelity. The architecture, from crumbling castles to gothic cathedrals, and creature design, from gargoyles to hydra, are memorable, and lighting helps create a lonely, melancholic atmosphere. Music is used sparingly, mainly in boss battles and at the central shrine, which gives it real impact.
Technically, the original release struggled with frame rate in some areas, and its PC version became infamous for a locked low resolution. The 2018 Remastered edition addressed many of these issues, while leaving the core design largely intact.
Who it is for
This is essential for players interested in the history of game design and for anyone who enjoys challenging, exploratory action. Newcomers should expect a steep learning curve and very little guidance. Those who prefer clear objectives and explicit storytelling may find it opaque, but many players who initially struggle find the persistence becomes part of the appeal.
What works
- A world that folds back on itself through brilliant shortcuts
- Deliberate, weighty combat that rewards patience and observation
- Environmental storytelling that makes lore a reward for curiosity
- Asynchronous online features that make solitude feel shared
What doesn’t
- Later areas feel rushed and markedly less refined
- Some bosses and zones are awkward rather than fairly difficult
- The original PC version was a notoriously poor port
Head to head
- Story
- 9.19.0
- Gameplay
- 9.59.6
- Longevity
- 9.38.8
- Presentation
- 8.69.2
Dark Souls edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
The verdict
Dark Souls earns an exceptional score for its extraordinary world design, its influential combat and its approach to storytelling. A rushed second half and some technical roughness keep it a fraction short of perfection, but its importance and its enduring quality make it one of the essential games of all time.





