Skip to content

Head to head

Dept. Q vs Mare of Easttown

Mare of Easttown takes it by 0.2, 8.4 against 8.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Dept. Q
Dept. Q

2025 · Excellent

  • Matthew Goode makes Carl Morck rude, funny and wounded in the same scene
  • The basement trio of Carl, Akram and Rose is a team worth returning to
  • The central case stretches thin across nine long episodes
Cover of Mare of Easttown
Mare of Easttown

2021 · Excellent

  • Kate Winslet gives a lived-in, unglamorous and completely convincing lead
  • Easttown feels like a real, tightly knit community
  • A crowded field of suspects leans on red herrings

Where the gap is

Craft
8.18.2
Story
7.68.2
Characters
8.78.8
Performances
8.89.3

At a glance

FactDept. QMare of Easttown
Released29 May 202518 April 2021
Created byScott Frank, Chandni LakhaniBrad Ingelsby
StarringMatthew Goode, Alexej Manvelov, Leah ByrneKate Winslet, Julianne Nicholson, Jean Smart
NetworkNetflixHBO
Seasons1 (a second season in production)1
Episodes9 in the first season7
GenreDrama · Thriller · CrimeDrama · Crime · Mystery

The two verdicts

Dept. Q

Dept. Q: a cold-case drama that cares more about its misfits than its mystery

Dept. Q is a crime series whose people are better than its plot, and that is not a bad problem to have. Matthew Goode's Carl Morck is a vivid, funny, damaged lead, the basement team around him is the best ensemble a streaming procedural has assembled in some time, and the Edinburgh setting gives the whole thing a character of its own. The score is held below the top of the range by a central case stretched past its natural length and a middle stretch that loses momentum. Those are real faults, and patient viewers will forgive them, because by the end of the first season the reason to come back is not the next case but the three people who will be working it.

Read the full review →

Mare of Easttown

Mare of Easttown: a small-town murder mystery with a big, bruised heart

Mare of Easttown earns an 8.4 for Kate Winslet's superb central performance, a strong supporting cast and a mystery that is both cleverly built and emotionally resonant. Its reliance on red herrings, thinly drawn subplots and conventional visual style prevent it from reaching the very top tier, but it is an exemplary limited series.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.