Skip to content
Series reviewExcellent

Dept. Q · 2025

Dept. Q: a cold-case drama that cares more about its misfits than its mystery

Dept. Q review. Scott Frank's Edinburgh adaptation of Jussi Adler-Olsen is a sharp, funny, well-cast crime drama with a case that sags in the middle.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda8 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

The best thing in Dept. Q is not the case. It is a cluttered basement under an Edinburgh police station, three people nobody upstairs wants, and a detective who has decided that the only way to survive his own guilt is to be unbearable to everyone around him. Scott Frank, who made The Queen's Gambit and Godless for Netflix, has turned Jussi Adler-Olsen's Danish procedural into something closer to a character study with a crime attached, and the series is at its strongest when it forgets, briefly, that it is supposed to be solving anything.

8.2
Editorial score
#57
Of 109 series reviewed
2025
Released
8.8
Best at: Performances

That is both its charm and its limit. The mystery at the centre of the first season, the disappearance of a prosecutor, is competently built and occasionally gripping, but it is spread across nine episodes that run as long as seventy minutes, and the middle of the season treads water. What keeps a viewer watching through the slack is the company. Matthew Goode has rarely been better, the supporting cast is uniformly strong, and the dialogue has a dry Scottish bite that most streaming crime dramas would not dare.

For viewers who come to it for Frank rather than for the genre, the earlier limited series makes a natural second stop.

The premise

Carl Morck is a detective chief inspector who is very good at his job and very bad at everything around it. The series opens with a shooting at a crime scene that leaves his partner, DI James Hardy, paralysed and a young constable dead, and Carl physically recovered but unable to look at what happened. He comes back to work on condition that he sees a therapist, Rachel Irving, and finds that his superiors have a use for an officer nobody wants to partner with: a new unit for cold cases, set up in the basement, in a posting that looks a great deal like a way of keeping him out of sight.

The unit is Carl and whoever will tolerate him. That turns out to be Akram Salim, a Syrian refugee who was a police officer at home and has a calm, unnerving way of getting people to talk, and Rose Dickson, a young detective constable with her own reasons for wanting a desk away from everyone else. Their first file is the case of Merritt Lingard, a prosecutor who vanished years earlier and whose disappearance was closed with an easy explanation that never quite held. The series lets the viewer see more than Carl can, which builds dread rather than surprise.

Adler-Olsen's novels have been filmed before, in Danish, and the books were already popular well beyond Denmark. The history matters because the series is a translation in two senses: from Danish into Scots-inflected English, and from a run of films into long-form television.

  1. 2007

    Jussi Adler-Olsen publishes the first Department Q novel in Denmark

  2. 2013

    The first of a run of Danish film adaptations reaches cinemas

  3. 2024

    Scott Frank's series films in Edinburgh between February and June

  4. 2025

    The nine-episode first season premieres on Netflix on 29 May

  5. 2025

    Netflix commissions a second season in August

  6. 2026

    Second-season production under way in Scotland

Dept. Q
Dept. QNetflix, via TMDB

Characters first

The relocation to Edinburgh could have been a gimmick, the kind of move a streamer makes to tick a regional box. Here it changes the texture of every scene. The city is grey stone, wet tenements, institutional corridors and a coastline that looks colder than it needs to. The Scottish characters speak in a register of insult that is half affection, and Carl, an Englishman among them, is outnumbered in a way that feels earned rather than written in.

The basement trio is where the series puts its heart. Akram is the most interesting creation: patient, polite, faintly terrifying when he needs to be, and given a backstory the writers wisely hold at arm's length in the opening episodes. Rose is the comic engine, chatty and quick, but the show is careful to let her nerves show through the jokes. Carl treats them both with contempt for about an episode, and the slow shift from contempt to something like loyalty is the real plot of the season.

Away from the basement, the therapy sessions with Rachel Irving give Carl a place to be honest by accident. These scenes are short and talky and among the best in the show, because Carl's defence mechanism is wit and the therapist is the one character who refuses to laugh.

How it feels

Pace
5/10
Brisk opening, a long plateau in the middle stretch
Plot density
6/10
One central case, a few station subplots around it
Humour
7/10
Dry and frequent, mostly at Carl's expense
Darkness
8/10
Violence is rare but the subject matter is grim
Comfort
6/10
The team becomes a reason to return
Watch
Dept. Q — trailer

Performances

Matthew Goode has spent years being the charming one in other people's stories. Carl Morck lets him be the difficult one in his own, and he plays it with real precision. The rudeness is funny until it isn't; the guilt is never announced, only visible in the way he refuses to sit still. It is a lead performance that makes a familiar type, the brilliant detective nobody can stand, feel lived in rather than borrowed.

Alexej Manvelov is the discovery. His Akram does very little and conveys a great deal, and the series trusts him with long silent stretches that a lesser show would fill with exposition. Leah Byrne gives Rose a nervy brightness that keeps the basement scenes moving. Chloe Pirrie, as the missing prosecutor seen in her life before the disappearance, plays a woman whose composure is her armour, and makes the case matter beyond its mechanics. Kelly Macdonald, in a smaller role than her billing suggests, is excellent as the therapist who sees straight through Carl, and Jamie Sives brings a bitter dignity to Hardy that the show uses sparingly and well.

Gallery · 3 imagesNetflix, via TMDB · Netflix

Craft and pace

Frank directs six of the nine episodes himself, with Elisa Amoruso taking the middle three, and the series has the unhurried, carefully framed look that marked his earlier work for Netflix. Interiors are dim and warm; the basement is a mess of boxes and old files that the camera seems to enjoy. Carlos Rafael Rivera's score, low strings and a nagging motif, keeps the tension present without leaning on it.

The weakness is structure. Episode runtimes range from 42 minutes to more than an hour, and the case does not always have enough material to fill them. Around the middle of the season, threads around station politics and Carl's home life are given room they do not need, and the investigation slows to accommodate them. The final run tightens considerably, but a viewer will need to trust the show through a slack stretch, and some will drift.

Season by season
SeasonYearEpisodesIn brief
Season 120259A strong team and a stretched case; the characters carry it
Season 2In productionNot yet announcedCommissioned in August 2025, with Matthew Goode returning as Carl

Where it sits

The obvious comparison is with other character-led crime dramas where the procedure matters less than the people doing it. Dept. Q is warmer and funnier than most of them, and less interested in a community than in a single team. The nearest in our catalogue is the Pennsylvania small-town drama that made a detective's private wreckage the real subject.

Head to head

Craft
8.18.2
Story
7.68.2
Characters
8.78.8
Performances
8.89.3

Mare of Easttown edges it by 0.2. See them side by side

Where Mare of Easttown folds its detective into a town that knows her too well, Dept. Q isolates its lead in a basement and makes him earn his way back to other people. Both shows understand that a case is most interesting as a pressure applied to a character. Frank's earlier *The Queen's Gambit* is a useful companion too, for its patience with a gifted, difficult protagonist.

For you if

  • Viewers who watch crime drama for the detectives rather than the twists
  • Anyone who liked Matthew Goode and wanted to see him play against type
  • Fans of Scottish crime fiction and dark, dry humour

Not for you if

  • Viewers who want a tight, eight-hour mystery with no subplots
  • Anyone sensitive to sustained scenes of cruelty and distress
  • People who already find the brilliant-but-impossible detective a tired figure

The whole of the first season is available now, and there is no reason to wait for the second before starting; it is self-contained enough to stand on its own.

For viewers who come to it for Frank rather than for the genre, the earlier limited series makes a natural second stop.

What works

  • Matthew Goode makes Carl Morck rude, funny and wounded in the same scene
  • The basement trio of Carl, Akram and Rose is a team worth returning to
  • Edinburgh is used as a working city, not a postcard of the Royal Mile
  • Dialogue with real wit, which the genre rarely bothers with

What doesn’t

  • The central case stretches thin across nine long episodes
  • Episode lengths swing from 42 to 71 minutes, and the pacing swings with them
  • Some subplots around the station's politics never quite pay off
ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Dept. Q is a crime series whose people are better than its plot, and that is not a bad problem to have. Matthew Goode's Carl Morck is a vivid, funny, damaged lead, the basement team around him is the best ensemble a streaming procedural has assembled in some time, and the Edinburgh setting gives the whole thing a character of its own. The score is held below the top of the range by a central case stretched past its natural length and a middle stretch that loses momentum. Those are real faults, and patient viewers will forgive them, because by the end of the first season the reason to come back is not the next case but the three people who will be working it.

Quick answers

Is Dept. Q worth watching?

Voxizer scores Dept. Q (2025) 8.2 out of 10 — excellent. Dept. Q is a crime series whose people are better than its plot, and that is not a bad problem to have.

Who will enjoy Dept. Q?

Viewers who watch crime drama for the detectives rather than the twists. Anyone who liked Matthew Goode and wanted to see him play against type. Fans of Scottish crime fiction and dark, dry humour.

Who should skip Dept. Q?

Viewers who want a tight, eight-hour mystery with no subplots. Anyone sensitive to sustained scenes of cruelty and distress. People who already find the brilliant-but-impossible detective a tired figure.

What is Dept. Q like, in short?

A cold-case procedural that works best as a portrait of three misfits in a basement. Matthew Goode gives Carl Morck enough wit and damage to carry the whole season. Edinburgh replaces Copenhagen, and the move feels natural rather than cosmetic. The central mystery is solid but over-extended; the middle episodes drag.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Dept. Q yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for series: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.