Skip to content

Head to head

Descender vs Fables

Dead level: both score 7.9. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Descender
Descender

2015 · Good

  • Dustin Nguyen's painted pages give planets and machines a soft, melancholy beauty
  • TIM-21 is a genuinely touching lead whose innocence drives the drama
  • The galactic politics are sketched thinly for such a big canvas
Cover of Fables
Fables

2002 · Good

  • A witty, endlessly fertile premise that reinvents public-domain characters
  • Bigby Wolf and Snow White are a compelling, prickly central pairing
  • Arcs after the Adversary conflict meander and repeat familiar beats

Where the gap is

Art
9.08.3
Story
7.67.8
Pacing
7.17.0
Characters
7.88.4

At a glance

FactDescenderFables
Released4 March 20151 July 2002
WriterJeff LemireBill Willingham
ArtistDustin NguyenMark Buckingham
PublisherImage ComicsVertigo
Issues32150 (original Vertigo run)
GenreAdventure · Sci-FiDrama · Fantasy

The two verdicts

Descender

Descender is a watercolour space opera with a robot boy's heart at its centre

Descender offers a lovable protagonist, sincere themes and some of the most beautiful pages in modern mainstream comics. Its politics are thin, its action can be muddy and its ending feels hurried, which keeps it from the level of Lemire's very best. A 7.9 marks a good, heartfelt series that is well worth reading for its art and its robot boy.

Read the full review →

Fables

Fables is a brilliant fairy-tale war saga that outlives its own best story

At its best, Fables is inventive, funny and gripping, with a cast that makes centuries-old characters feel newly alive and a first half that deserves to be called a modern classic. Its sprawling, slower second half, uneven allegory and inconsistent handling of women weigh down the full run. A 7.9 reflects an excellent core story within a series that went on longer than its best ideas.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.