Descender · 2015
Descender is a watercolour space opera with a robot boy's heart at its centre
Descender pairs Jeff Lemire's tender story of the android TIM-21 with Dustin Nguyen's watercolour galaxy, though its sprawling plot ends in a rush.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Descender is Jeff Lemire doing Pinocchio in space, and it is at its best when it stays close to that simple, aching idea. A little robot who only wants to see his human family again is dropped into a galaxy that has decided every machine is a murderer, and the result is a story about prejudice, grief and what it means to be real.
- 7.9
- Editorial score
- #43
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 32
- Issues
Dustin Nguyen's watercolours make it one of the loveliest science-fiction comics of the last decade. The plot around TIM-21 is less assured, growing busier and more crowded until the ending has to sprint to catch up.
Dustin Nguyen's watercolours make it one of the loveliest science-fiction comics of the last decade.
A galaxy that fears machines
The setup is compelling. The Harvesters, robots of colossal size, appeared without warning, wrought catastrophe and then vanished, leaving behind a traumatised civilisation that turned its fury on its own androids. Scrappers roam the systems hunting robots for bounty, and anti-machine cults preach extermination. When TIM-21 wakes on the mining moon where his human family once lived, his design turns out to share something with the Harvesters, and suddenly governments, bounty hunters and a robot resistance all want him.
Lemire assembles a travelling party around him: Dr Jin Quon, the disgraced scientist who designed his model line; Telsa, a council officer; the loyal robot dog Bandit; and Driller, a mining robot with a vocabulary built for demolition. Their banter gives the story warmth, and Quon's guilt makes a strong counterweight to TIM's innocence.
Nguyen's painted galaxy
Nguyen's art is the book's defining feature. He works in soft watercolour washes over fine line work, so planets glow, starships look fragile and TIM's face can register tiny shifts of emotion. The palette moves from icy blues on dead colonies to rusty oranges in scrap yards and lurid pinks in alien cities. Flashback sequences of TIM's childhood home have a hazy, nostalgic quality that makes his longing palpable.
The same technique struggles in big battles. When dozens of robots clash or ships explode, the washes can blur figures together, and the choreography becomes harder to read than it should be.
The rush to the end
Thirty-two issues sounds generous, but Descender is juggling a lot: robot rebellion, planetary politics, a mystery about the Harvesters' origin, and multiple rival factions. The council leaders, the robot resistance and the Gnishian empire are all introduced with promise and then given relatively little room. The final arc delivers big revelations and a large-scale conflict at a pace that leaves several relationships underexplored, clearly with one eye on the fantasy sequel series, Ascender, that followed.
That said, the emotional threads involving TIM, his brother model and the human boy he was built to love are resolved with care.
Who it is for
Descender suits readers who like gentle, character-driven science fiction in the vein of WALL-E or The Iron Giant rather than hard military space opera. It is also a good entry point to Lemire's creator-owned work for those who know him from Sweet Tooth or Black Hammer. Older children and teenagers can enjoy it, though there is some violence.
What works
- Dustin Nguyen's painted pages give planets and machines a soft, melancholy beauty
- TIM-21 is a genuinely touching lead whose innocence drives the drama
- Strong supporting robots, especially the hulking, blunt-spoken Driller
- Asks sincere questions about personhood without lecturing
What doesn’t
- The galactic politics are sketched thinly for such a big canvas
- The final arc compresses major revelations into too few issues
- Watercolour action scenes can be hard to follow
Head to head
- Art
- 9.09.1
- Story
- 7.67.0
- Pacing
- 7.16.8
- Characters
- 7.87.9
Descender edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Descender offers a lovable protagonist, sincere themes and some of the most beautiful pages in modern mainstream comics. Its politics are thin, its action can be muddy and its ending feels hurried, which keeps it from the level of Lemire's very best. A 7.9 marks a good, heartfelt series that is well worth reading for its art and its robot boy.




