Paper Girls · 2015
Paper Girls is a neon time-travel adventure that grows more tangled than thrilling
Paper Girls, by Brian K. Vaughan and Cliff Chiang, sends four 1980s newspaper girls into a time war, with superb art and a plot that gets knotted late on.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Paper Girls opens with a near-perfect hook. Four young girls on their bikes, in the dark, on the morning after Halloween, in a quiet suburb where something has just gone very wrong. Brian K. Vaughan and Cliff Chiang bottle the feeling of 1980s adventure films and then take it somewhere much stranger, as their heroines are thrown across time and forced to wonder what kind of adults they will become.
- 7.5
- Editorial score
- #49
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 30
- Issues
The early issues are among the best-looking and most gripping science-fiction comics of the decade. Over time, though, the story's mechanics grow so convoluted that the characters sometimes struggle to stay in focus.
The early issues are among the best-looking and most gripping science-fiction comics of the decade.
Four girls and a time war
Vaughan's greatest strength is character. Erin is anxious and responsible, Mac is a chain-smoking kid from a rough home with a mouth to match, KJ is guarded and sharp, and Tiffany is a nerdy, practical optimist. Their dynamic is prickly and believable, and Vaughan lets them be rude, frightened and funny in ways that avoid nostalgia-tinted cuteness.
The central science-fiction concept involves warring camps of time travellers, with older and younger factions each trying to control history. When the girls are displaced to other eras, including encounters with their adult selves, the series finds its most interesting theme: what it means to confront the gap between who you hoped to be and who you are.
Chiang and Wilson
The art is exceptional. Cliff Chiang's clean, confident line gives every character a distinct silhouette and expressive face, and his designs for strange creatures and futuristic armour are memorable without clutter. Matt Wilson's colours are equally important, using a vivid palette of hot pinks, purples and cool blues that feel like a 1980s film poster, while also signalling shifts in time and place. Jared K. Fletcher's lettering, including the invented language and glyphs, adds texture.
Even when the plot becomes difficult to follow, the pages remain a delight, and Chiang's storytelling during action scenes stays admirably clear.
A plot that gets away
The weakness is structural. Vaughan introduces multiple factions, time jumps and technologies, but explains relatively little, trusting readers to piece it together. That mystery is intriguing at first but becomes frustrating as the series progresses, especially as future characters speak in a deliberately obscure slang. Several middle arcs feel like detours, and the conclusion, while emotionally considered, resolves the mythology in a way some readers found abstract and unsatisfying.
The strongest material remains the character work, which keeps the book readable even as the time war becomes tangled.
Who it is for
Paper Girls suits readers who enjoy nostalgic, character-driven genre fiction in the vein of Stranger Things or The Goonies, but with sharper edges and far more swearing. It is also a great choice for fans of Vaughan's other series, particularly Y: The Last Man and Saga. The 2022 television adaptation offers a different take, but the comic has the distinctive art that defines the story.
What works
- Cliff Chiang's crisp art and Matt Wilson's neon palette are gorgeous
- The four girls are distinctive, funny and refreshingly abrasive
- Meeting their future selves raises sharp questions about growing up
- An electrifying first arc with a wonderfully eerie small-town mood
What doesn’t
- The time-war mythology becomes confusing and underexplained
- Invented future slang and factions create a steep barrier
- Later arcs lose the tight focus and momentum of the opening
Head to head
- Art
- 9.19.0
- Story
- 7.07.6
- Pacing
- 6.87.1
- Characters
- 7.97.8
Descender edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Paper Girls has a fantastic setup, beautifully rendered art and four vivid central characters, making its first arcs a real pleasure. An overcomplicated mythology, opaque slang and a loss of momentum later on hold it back. A 7.5 reflects a good and often dazzling series that does not fully deliver on its early promise.




