Skip to content

Head to head

Foundation vs The Walking Dead

Dead level: both score 7.0. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Foundation
Foundation

2021 · Good

  • Lee Pace's imperious Brother Day is a commanding, layered creation
  • The cloned-emperor storyline is a smart addition to Asimov's ideas
  • The first season meanders and buries its ideas under subplots
Cover of The Walking Dead
The Walking Dead

2010 · Good

  • The early seasons deliver bleak, genuinely gripping survival horror
  • Greg Nicotero's makeup effects make the walkers grotesquely convincing
  • Long stretches repeat the same cycle of new community and new villain

Where the gap is

Craft
9.07.9
Story
6.66.4
Characters
6.97.4
Performances
7.87.6

At a glance

FactFoundationThe Walking Dead
Released24 September 202131 October 2010
Created byDavid S Goyer—
StarringJared Harris, Lee Pace, Laura BirnNorman Reedus, Melissa McBride, Andrew Lincoln
NetworkApple TV+AMC
Seasons211
Episodes20177
GenreSci-Fi · DramaAction · Drama · Horror

The two verdicts

Foundation

Foundation: gorgeous, ambitious Asimov that took a season to find its footing

Foundation scores 7.0 across its first two seasons: its visual ambition, the inspired clone-emperor storyline and Lee Pace's performance deserve considerable credit, and the second season is clearly stronger. The meandering first season, uneven characterisation and additions that trade Asimov's intellect for spectacle keep it firmly in good-but-flawed territory.

Read the full review →

The Walking Dead

The Walking Dead: a zombie phenomenon that shambled on long after its best years

The Walking Dead's early seasons are gripping and influential, with strong performances and outstanding effects. Its later years, however, were marked by repetition, manipulative plotting and sluggish pacing that eroded its impact. A 7.0 reflects a good series with a brilliant start, weighed down by an overlong run.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.