Skip to content

Head to head

Her vs Lady Bird

Dead level: both score 8.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Her
Her

2013 · Excellent

  • Scarlett Johansson creates a vivid character through voice alone
  • Joaquin Phoenix is vulnerable, funny and deeply sympathetic
  • The middle stretch loses momentum as the relationship settles
Cover of Lady Bird
Lady Bird

2017 · Excellent

  • Saoirse Ronan and Laurie Metcalf are extraordinary together
  • Sharply specific about class, money and hometown embarrassment
  • Its episodic structure can feel slight at times

Where the gap is

Craft
8.98.1
Story
8.68.3
Direction
8.88.6
Performances
9.19.3

At a glance

FactHerLady Bird
Released18 December 20133 November 2017
DirectorSpike JonzeGreta Gerwig
StarringJoaquin Phoenix, Amy Adams, Rooney MaraSaoirse Ronan, Timothee Chalamet, Laurie Metcalf
Runtime126 minutes94 minutes
StudioAnnapurna Pictures, Warner Bros. EntertainmentA24
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · RomanceDrama · Comedy

The two verdicts

Her

Her: Spike Jonze's tender, prescient love story between a man and his software

Her is a thoughtful, beautifully made and emotionally honest film that has only become more resonant with time. Its pacing sags in the middle and some supporting characters are underexplored, but the central performances and the delicacy of Jonze's vision are exceptional. It earns an 8.7.

Read the full review →

Lady Bird

Lady Bird: Greta Gerwig's funny, piercing portrait of a mother and daughter

Lady Bird is a funny, perceptive and emotionally rich film, anchored by two superb performances. Its slight, episodic structure and familiar beats are small limitations against the precision and warmth of Gerwig's writing and direction. It earns an 8.7 as one of the finest coming-of-age films of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.