Skip to content

Head to head

Ice Cream Man vs Paper Girls

Paper Girls takes it by 0.1, 7.5 against 7.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Ice Cream Man
Ice Cream Man

2018 · Good

  • Formally adventurous issues play with structure, layout and genre
  • Martin Morazzo's clean, precise line makes the grotesque doubly shocking
  • Quality swings sharply between inspired issues and slighter ones
Cover of Paper Girls
Paper Girls

2015 · Good

  • Cliff Chiang's crisp art and Matt Wilson's neon palette are gorgeous
  • The four girls are distinctive, funny and refreshingly abrasive
  • The time-war mythology becomes confusing and underexplained

Where the gap is

Art
8.29.1
Story
7.37.0
Pacing
7.56.8
Characters
7.07.9

At a glance

FactIce Cream ManPaper Girls
Released17 January 20187 October 2015
WriterW. Maxwell PrinceBrian K. Vaughan
ArtistMartín Morazzo—
PublisherImage ComicsImage Comics
Issues3630
GenreBlack comedy · HorrorAdventure · Sci-Fi

The two verdicts

Ice Cream Man

Ice Cream Man serves suburban horror in wildly inventive, uneven single scoops

Ice Cream Man is a daring and genuinely unnerving series, with sharp art and some unforgettable single issues that stretch what a horror comic can do. Its unevenness, occasional gratuitous bleakness and thin connecting mythology keep it from greatness. A 7.4 reflects a good, distinctive anthology whose highs are well worth the lows.

Read the full review →

Paper Girls

Paper Girls is a neon time-travel adventure that grows more tangled than thrilling

Paper Girls has a fantastic setup, beautifully rendered art and four vivid central characters, making its first arcs a real pleasure. An overcomplicated mythology, opaque slang and a loss of momentum later on hold it back. A 7.5 reflects a good and often dazzling series that does not fully deliver on its early promise.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.