Skip to content

Head to head

Ice Cream Man vs Something is Killing the Children

Ice Cream Man takes it by 0.1, 7.4 against 7.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Ice Cream Man
Ice Cream Man

2018 · Good

  • Formally adventurous issues play with structure, layout and genre
  • Martin Morazzo's clean, precise line makes the grotesque doubly shocking
  • Quality swings sharply between inspired issues and slighter ones
Cover of Something is Killing the Children
  • Erica Slaughter is an instantly iconic, enigmatic horror protagonist
  • Werther Dell'Edera's scratchy art makes the monsters genuinely unnerving
  • Heavily decompressed pacing makes arcs feel longer than their story

Where the gap is

Art
8.28.4
Story
7.37.0
Pacing
7.56.4
Characters
7.07.8

At a glance

FactIce Cream ManSomething is Killing the Children
Released17 January 20184 September 2019
WriterW. Maxwell PrinceJames Tynion IV
ArtistMartín MorazzoWerther Dell'Edera
PublisherImage ComicsBoom! Studios
Issues3640
GenreBlack comedy · HorrorMystery · Horror

The two verdicts

Ice Cream Man

Ice Cream Man serves suburban horror in wildly inventive, uneven single scoops

Ice Cream Man is a daring and genuinely unnerving series, with sharp art and some unforgettable single issues that stretch what a horror comic can do. Its unevenness, occasional gratuitous bleakness and thin connecting mythology keep it from greatness. A 7.4 reflects a good, distinctive anthology whose highs are well worth the lows.

Read the full review →

Something is Killing the Children

Something is Killing the Children finds a fierce new horror hero, then stretches her thin

Something is Killing the Children has a superb lead character, striking art and an excellent opening arc that shows how effective modern horror comics can be. Its slow, decompressed pacing, mannered dialogue and increasingly bloated mythology keep it from greatness. A 7.3 reflects a good horror series whose best elements are strong enough to carry its weaker stretches.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.