Something is Killing the Children · 2019
Something is Killing the Children finds a fierce new horror hero, then stretches her thin
Something is Killing the Children, by James Tynion IV and Werther Dell'Edera, pairs a superb monster-hunter lead with moody art, though its pacing drags.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Something is Killing the Children announces itself with an image as strong as any horror comic in recent memory: a young woman in a bandanna, carrying a stuffed octopus, walking into a town where children are dying. James Tynion IV and Werther Dell'Edera have built a franchise around Erica Slaughter, and she is compelling enough to justify it.
- 7.3
- Editorial score
- #51
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2019
- Released
- 40
- Issues
The series is at its best when it plays as intimate, dread-soaked small-town horror. As it expands into an ever-larger mythology about the organisation behind Erica, it loses some of that focus, and its deliberate pacing can become a slog.
The series is at its best when it plays as intimate, dread-soaked small-town horror.
A town and its monsters
The opening arc is excellent. Archer's Peak is a quiet, grieving town where children have vanished, and the adults insist on rational explanations while the kids know something is out there. James, who survived a night in the woods, is the only one willing to speak about what he saw, and his trauma gives the story emotional weight. Erica's arrival changes everything, and her dry, unflappable manner contrasts beautifully with the town's fear.
Tynion is skilled at building dread through character. Adults with secrets, bullied teenagers, grieving parents and suspicious police form a web that feels credible, and the horror comes as much from the community's failures as from the monsters.
Dell'Edera and Muerto
Werther Dell'Edera's art is the key to the book's atmosphere. His lines are loose and scratchy, with heavy shadow, and his monsters are glimpsed in shapes and fragments before being revealed in terrifying detail. He handles quiet moments well, too, with tired faces and empty streets that give the town a lived-in feeling. His action is kinetic and brutal when Erica finally fights.
Miquel Muerto's colours are equally important, using limited palettes of cold blues, sickly greens and blood reds to create a cinematic, oppressive mood.
Slower than it needs to be
The series' main problem is pacing. Tynion writes in a very decompressed style, and many issues contain relatively little plot, lingering on atmosphere, conversation and repeated beats. In collected form, this can make the arcs feel longer than their stories require. The dialogue can also become mannered, with characters repeating phrases and circling the same ideas.
The expanding mythology is a double-edged sword. The Order of St George, with its rival houses, rules and internal politics, adds intriguing context and has spun off into its own series, House of Slaughter. But the more time the book spends on the Order, the less it feels like the lean, frightening horror story it began as, and the lore can seem overcomplicated.
Who it is for
Something is Killing the Children suits horror fans who enjoy slow-burn stories in the vein of Stephen King's small-town novels, as well as readers who love a strong, mysterious protagonist. Those who prefer brisk, tightly plotted comics may find it frustrating. It contains frequent violence against children, so it is not for the faint-hearted.
What works
- Erica Slaughter is an instantly iconic, enigmatic horror protagonist
- Werther Dell'Edera's scratchy art makes the monsters genuinely unnerving
- Miquel Muerto's colours give each scene a moody, cinematic tone
- The first arc is a tense, atmospheric small-town horror story
What doesn’t
- Heavily decompressed pacing makes arcs feel longer than their story
- The Order of St George's lore bloats the narrative
- Dialogue can be mannered and heavy with repetition
Head to head
- Art
- 8.49.2
- Story
- 7.09.1
- Pacing
- 6.48.3
- Characters
- 7.89.0
Locke & Key edges it by 1.6. See them side by side
The verdict
Something is Killing the Children has a superb lead character, striking art and an excellent opening arc that shows how effective modern horror comics can be. Its slow, decompressed pacing, mannered dialogue and increasingly bloated mythology keep it from greatness. A 7.3 reflects a good horror series whose best elements are strong enough to carry its weaker stretches.




