Skip to content

Head to head

Locke & Key vs Something is Killing the Children

Locke & Key takes it by 1.6, 8.9 against 7.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Locke & Key
Locke & Key

2008 · Excellent

  • Every key is a plot device and a metaphor at once, and the series never forgets either
  • Rodríguez's clean line keeps the gore legible and the quiet scenes devastating
  • The opening volume's violence is blunt enough to put off readers it later rewards
Cover of Something is Killing the Children
  • Erica Slaughter is an instantly iconic, enigmatic horror protagonist
  • Werther Dell'Edera's scratchy art makes the monsters genuinely unnerving
  • Heavily decompressed pacing makes arcs feel longer than their story

Where the gap is

Art
9.28.4
Story
9.17.0
Pacing
8.36.4
Characters
9.07.8

At a glance

FactLocke & KeySomething is Killing the Children
Released20 February 20084 September 2019
WriterJoe HillJames Tynion IV
ArtistGabriel Rodríguez, Jay FotosWerther Dell'Edera
PublisherIDW Publishing, MiladyBoom! Studios
Issues37 issues in six arcs, February 2008 to December 201340
GenreFantasy · Graphic Novel · MysteryMystery · Horror

The two verdicts

Locke & Key

Locke & Key: a haunted-house comic that is really about grief, and plays fair to the last door

Locke & Key earns its reputation by doing something few horror series manage: it gets more humane as it gets more frightening. Hill's rules hold from the first key to the last, Rodríguez gives the whole thing a clarity that makes both the scares and the grief impossible to look away from, and the Locke children are drawn and written as people rather than victims. The score stops short of the top tier because the opening volume is harder going than the rest of the series deserves, and because the middle arcs take their time finding the thread. Read through those stretches. The final volumes deliver one of the most satisfying endings of any American comic of its era, and they do it without cheating.

Read the full review →

Something is Killing the Children

Something is Killing the Children finds a fierce new horror hero, then stretches her thin

Something is Killing the Children has a superb lead character, striking art and an excellent opening arc that shows how effective modern horror comics can be. Its slow, decompressed pacing, mannered dialogue and increasingly bloated mythology keep it from greatness. A 7.3 reflects a good horror series whose best elements are strong enough to carry its weaker stretches.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.