Skip to content

Head to head

It Was Just an Accident vs Moonlight

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of It Was Just an Accident
It Was Just an Accident

2025 · Essential

  • A premise built on doubt, so every scene re-opens the question of who is in the van
  • Long, patient takes that let arguments run until they turn into something else
  • The middle stretch circles the same dilemma one or two times too often
Cover of Moonlight
Moonlight

2016 · Essential

  • Three actors form a seamless, heartbreaking portrait of Chiron
  • Mahershala Ali gives Juan warmth, dignity and contradiction
  • Long ellipses between chapters leave some events unexplored

Where the gap is

Craft
8.59.1
Story
9.18.9
Direction
9.49.4
Performances
9.09.5

At a glance

FactIt Was Just an AccidentMoonlight
Released20 May 202521 October 2016
DirectorJafar PanahiBarry Jenkins
StarringVahid Mobasseri, Mariam Afshari, Ebrahim AziziNaomie Harris, Trevante Rhodes, André Holland
Runtime104 minutes111 minutes
StudioLes Films Pelléas, Bidibul ProductionsA24, Plan B Entertainment
GenreDrama · Thriller · Black comedyDrama

The two verdicts

It Was Just an Accident

It Was Just an Accident: a revenge thriller that keeps refusing to become one

*It Was Just an Accident* takes a premise that could have been a straightforward revenge thriller and turns it into something stranger and more searching: a film about how people who were harmed in the dark decide what justice looks like in daylight. Panahi's direction is controlled without being cold, his cast give the material a weight that feels earned, and the humour sharpens the horror instead of relieving it. The middle section loops once or twice too often, and the image is more practical than memorable, which keeps it just short of the very top tier. But it is a gripping, humane and quietly furious piece of filmmaking, made at real personal risk, and it deserves the prize it won.

Read the full review →

Moonlight

Moonlight: Barry Jenkins' luminous, three-part portrait of a hidden life

Moonlight is a beautifully crafted and deeply moving film that tells a story of identity and love with rare grace. Its ellipses and restraint will not suit every viewer, but its performances, visual poetry and emotional honesty are exceptional. It earns a 9.1 as one of the defining films of its decade.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.