Skip to content

Head to head

Like a Rolling Stone vs Purple Rain

Like a Rolling Stone takes it by 0.2, 9.7 against 9.5. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Like a Rolling Stone
Like a Rolling Stone

1965 · Masterpiece

  • A chorus that turns contempt into something close to sympathy over four verses
  • Al Kooper's organ line, played by a guest who was not meant to be in the room
  • The mix is rough, with the organ and guitar crowding the voice in places
Cover of Purple Rain
Purple Rain

1984 · Masterpiece

  • A live club take kept almost whole, room noise and all
  • The last three minutes belong to a guitar, not a lyric
  • Eight minutes and forty-one seconds is a real commitment

Where the gap is

Production
8.89.2
Performance
9.89.8
Songwriting
9.99.4
Replay value
9.49.3

At a glance

FactLike a Rolling StonePurple Rain
Released20 July 196525 June 1984
ArtistBob DylanPrince, The Revolution
AlbumHighway 61 RevisitedPurple Rain
LabelColumbia RecordsWarner Bros. Records, Warner Records
Length6:138:41
GenreRock · Folk rockPop · Rock · Soul

The two verdicts

Like a Rolling Stone

Like a Rolling Stone: six minutes that broke the rules of the pop single

Few records have changed the terms of their own medium as directly as this one, and it is the reason the score sits above every other song in the catalogue. "Like a Rolling Stone" proved that a hit could be long, bitter, wordy and ambiguous, and it did so with a performance that still sounds alive rather than embalmed. The score sits in the top tier for the writing and the vocal, which are as good as popular music gets, and for the way the band's half-rehearsed urgency became the song's identity. It falls short of a perfect mark only because the recording itself is rough, and because sixty years of canonisation can make it feel like homework before it feels like a song. Get past that, and the question at its centre lands as hard as it did in 1965.

Read the full review →

Purple Rain

Purple Rain: a club benefit in Minneapolis that turned into a hymn

The score reflects a record that does something almost nobody attempts and then gets away with it: a slow, plain, eight-minute ballad, cut live in a club with a new guitarist on her first night, released essentially as played, and allowed to end with three minutes of guitar instead of a chorus. The songwriting is deliberately ordinary and the lyric is thin on the page, which is the only thing keeping it from a perfect mark. Everything else — the build, the vocal that gives up its composure on purpose, the solo, the coda that hands the song away — is as well judged as popular music gets. It is the rare standard that still sounds like an event rather than a fixture.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.