Skip to content

Head to head

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain vs Undertale

Dead level: both score 9.0. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain
  • Missions can be tackled in countless improvised ways with tools and buddies
  • Enemy adaptation forces players to vary tactics rather than repeat one trick
  • The second chapter leans heavily on harder replays of earlier missions
Cover of Undertale
Undertale

2015 · Essential

  • Every enemy can be spared, turning battles into character-driven puzzles
  • Sharp, warm humour and a memorable cast such as Sans, Papyrus and Toriel
  • Simple visuals may put off players expecting a polished look

Where the gap is

Story
6.89.4
Gameplay
9.88.6
Longevity
9.18.7
Presentation
9.08.2

At a glance

FactMetal Gear Solid V: The Phantom PainUndertale
Released1 September 201515 September 2015
DeveloperKojima ProductionsToby Fox, 8-4
PublisherKonamiFangamer, 8-4
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 4, Xbox OnePC (Windows), Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4
DirectorHideo Kojima—
EngineFox EngineGameMaker
GenreAction · Adventure · Open worldRPG · Indie

The two verdicts

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V: a stealth sandbox of genius around an unfinished story

As a stealth sandbox, The Phantom Pain is close to peerless, with a depth of systems and freedom that few games have approached. Its repetitive second half, sparse world and fragmented, unfinished story are real faults, but the brilliance of its moment-to-moment play still earns it a score of nine.

Read the full review →

Undertale

Undertale is a small RPG that remembers every choice, and makes them matter

Undertale combines inventive combat, memorable characters and a story that reacts meaningfully to player choices. Its bare-bones visuals and simple puzzles are obvious limitations, and much of its power only emerges on repeat play. Few games have used their own mechanics to say so much about kindness and consequence, which is why it scores this highly.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.