Skip to content

Head to head

Palworld vs Starfield

Palworld takes it by 0.1, 7.3 against 7.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Palworld
Palworld

2024 · Good

  • Putting captured creatures to work at bases makes automation delightfully tactile
  • Pals double as mounts and gliders, making traversal varied and fun
  • Many creature designs lean uncomfortably close to familiar monster series
Cover of Starfield
Starfield

2023 · Good

  • Faction questlines, especially the corporate espionage arc, are highly memorable
  • Deep ship builder allows creative and functional custom vessels
  • Menus and loading screens fragment exploration and break immersion

Where the gap is

Story
4.06.9
Gameplay
7.87.4
Longevity
7.98.2
Presentation
6.87.6

At a glance

FactPalworldStarfield
Released19 January 20246 September 2023
DeveloperPocketpairBethesda Game Studios
PublisherPocketpairBethesda Softworks
PlatformsPC (Windows), Xbox Series X|SPC (Windows), Xbox Series X|S
EngineUnreal Engine 5Creation Engine 2
GenreAdventure · Open world · Co-opRPG · Open world · Sci-Fi
Director—Todd Howard

The two verdicts

Palworld

Palworld: a derivative creature survival game that is dangerously fun anyway

Palworld succeeds by merging creature collection with survival crafting and automation, resulting in an addictive loop that is especially fun with friends. Its derivative designs, technical roughness and grindy later stages hold it back substantially, but its core ideas and sheer enjoyment still make it a good, if flawed, game.

Read the full review →

Starfield

Starfield: a vast Bethesda universe that too often feels far away

Starfield offers strong faction quests, satisfying combat and a superb ship builder, making it a good space RPG. However, fragmented exploration, repetitive procedural planets and a lacklustre main story prevent it from reaching the heights of Bethesda's best, earning it a good but notably flawed score.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.